Personal agents compared, pair by pair
Each comparison puts two products we have taken apart side by side on the same axes. We only build them for pairs we opened ourselves, which is why there are six and not sixty.
A comparison with the vendor's marketing on one side is the thing this site exists to replace. So every product here has a teardown of its own, and every row in every comparison comes from those teardowns rather than from a feature page. None of them ranks the two products, and none combines anything into a score.
- Muse vs InstinctCompared on what each one actually runsInstinct AI vs Muse, from our teardowns of both: where each runs, how you reach it, which asks before acting, phone calls, and which fits your errand.
- Pine vs TownA borrowed browser or a Mac footholdPine AI vs Town AI: Pine thinks on its servers and borrows a browser; Town's Mac app reaches your messages, contacts, screen and audio. From our teardowns.
- Instinct vs TownInvite, and who asks firstInstinct AI vs Town AI: Instinct is invite-only and publishes no price; Town publishes prices, starting with a free plan. Instinct asks on a card; Town asks in the routine's settings.
- Muse vs PineAnd what a machine of your own is actually forMeta Muse vs Pine AI: Muse gives every user a Linux VM in Meta's cloud; Pine runs its model on its servers and borrows a browser. From our own teardowns.
- Muse vs TownAnd two things people call a machineMeta Muse vs Town AI: Muse gives each user a Linux VM in Meta's cloud; Town's native Mac app reaches your messages and screen. From our own teardowns.
- Pine vs InstinctTwo products that look identical from one step backPine AI vs Instinct AI: both think on a server. Pine is built around calls and borrows your browser; Instinct lives in your messages and leases one.
Products we have recorded but not taken apart, which is most of the category, are on the landscape list. They don't get comparisons until they get teardowns.